Compare Garage Door Repair Pros in Rochester, NY
Work order · Rochester, NYEd. November 2026
- Updated
- November 10, 2026
- Companies ranked
- 21
- Ranked by
- Score of 100
- Paid slots
- Labeled, unranked
21 garage door repair companies in Rochester, NY are ranked by a published 0-100 score; #1 is Precision Garage Door of Rochester (94/100, 4.9 stars from 2,065 reviews). A typical torsion spring replacement costs $150 to $350 as of November 2026; get a written, itemized quote before you agree.
Request a callback
Request a callback
Your request goes to the top 20 companies listed on this page. We don't send marketing texts.
- Free to use
- Ranked by public ratings
Garage doors · Rochester, NY
$150–$350torsion spring replacement
Estimate as of November 2026, from the sources on the rate card below. Your quote may differ.
Before you book, ask for
- An itemized quote in writing
- The company's street address
- Its license and insurance status
Ranked by published score
- precisiondoor.net
- BBBA+ (BBB Accredited)
See how 94 adds up
- Rating
- 48.9/50
- 4.9 stars from 2065 reviews, adjusted toward 4.2
- Review volume
- 20/20
- 2,065 public reviews, log-scaled
- Completeness
- 20/20
- PhoneAddressLicenseHours
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 94/100
Rating source: precisiondoor.net (company website, self-reported). Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- serviceagent.ai directory
- BBBA+ (BBB Accredited)
See how 82 adds up
- Rating
- 43.6/50
- 4.4 stars from 87 reviews, adjusted toward 4.2
- Review volume
- 13/20
- 87 public reviews, log-scaled
- Completeness
- 15/20
- PhoneAddressLicenseHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 10/10
- 42 years, capped at 30
- Total
- 82/100
Rating source: serviceagent.ai directory. Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- serviceagent.ai directory
- BBBA+ (BBB Accredited, listed as FELLUCA OVERHEAD DOORS INC)
See how 80 adds up
- Rating
- 44.7/50
- 4.5 stars from 167 reviews, adjusted toward 4.2
- Review volume
- 14.8/20
- 167 public reviews, log-scaled
- Completeness
- 15/20
- PhoneAddressLicenseHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 80/100
Rating source: serviceagent.ai directory. Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- serviceagent.ai directory
See how 76 adds up
- Rating
- 49.5/50
- 5 stars from 294 reviews, adjusted toward 4.2
- Review volume
- 16.5/20
- 294 public reviews, log-scaled
- Completeness
- 5/20
- PhoneAddress: Not listedLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 76/100
Rating source: serviceagent.ai directory. Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- serviceagent.ai directory
- BBBA+ (BBB Accredited)
See how 76 adds up
- Rating
- 48.3/50
- 5 stars from 76 reviews, adjusted toward 4.2
- Review volume
- 12.6/20
- 76 public reviews, log-scaled
- Completeness
- 10/20
- PhoneAddressLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 76/100
Rating source: serviceagent.ai directory. Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- serviceagent.ai directory
See how 75 adds up
- Rating
- 46.3/50
- 4.7 stars from 116 reviews, adjusted toward 4.2
- Review volume
- 13.8/20
- 116 public reviews, log-scaled
- Completeness
- 10/20
- PhoneAddressLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 75/100
Rating source: serviceagent.ai directory. Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- serviceagent.ai directory
See how 73 adds up
- Rating
- 46.5/50
- 4.8 stars from 58 reviews, adjusted toward 4.2
- Review volume
- 11.8/20
- 58 public reviews, log-scaled
- Completeness
- 10/20
- PhoneAddressLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 73/100
Rating source: serviceagent.ai directory. Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- serviceagent.ai directory
See how 71 adds up
- Rating
- 48.5/50
- 5 stars from 86 reviews, adjusted toward 4.2
- Review volume
- 12.9/20
- 86 public reviews, log-scaled
- Completeness
- 5/20
- PhoneAddress: Not listedLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 71/100
Rating source: serviceagent.ai directory. Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- serviceagent.ai directory
See how 66 adds up
- Rating
- 46.1/50
- 4.9 stars from 28 reviews, adjusted toward 4.2
- Review volume
- 9.7/20
- 28 public reviews, log-scaled
- Completeness
- 5/20
- PhoneAddress: Not listedLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 66/100
Rating source: serviceagent.ai directory. Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- serviceagent.ai directory
See how 65 adds up
- Rating
- 46.1/50
- 5 stars from 21 reviews, adjusted toward 4.2
- Review volume
- 8.9/20
- 21 public reviews, log-scaled
- Completeness
- 5/20
- PhoneAddress: Not listedLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 65/100
Rating source: serviceagent.ai directory. Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- serviceagent.ai directory
See how 64 adds up
- Rating
- 44.2/50
- 4.6 stars from 24 reviews, adjusted toward 4.2
- Review volume
- 9.3/20
- 24 public reviews, log-scaled
- Completeness
- 5/20
- PhoneAddress: Not listedLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 64/100
Rating source: serviceagent.ai directory. Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- serviceagent.ai directory
See how 64 adds up
- Rating
- 45.1/50
- 4.8 stars from 22 reviews, adjusted toward 4.2
- Review volume
- 9.1/20
- 22 public reviews, log-scaled
- Completeness
- 5/20
- PhoneAddress: Not listedLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 64/100
Rating source: serviceagent.ai directory. Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- serviceagent.ai directory
See how 64 adds up
- Rating
- 45.6/50
- 5 stars from 16 reviews, adjusted toward 4.2
- Review volume
- 8.2/20
- 16 public reviews, log-scaled
- Completeness
- 5/20
- PhoneAddress: Not listedLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 64/100
Rating source: serviceagent.ai directory. Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- serviceagent.ai directory
See how 63 adds up
- Rating
- 45.2/50
- 5 stars from 13 reviews, adjusted toward 4.2
- Review volume
- 7.6/20
- 13 public reviews, log-scaled
- Completeness
- 5/20
- PhoneAddress: Not listedLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 63/100
Rating source: serviceagent.ai directory. Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- serviceagent.ai directory
See how 62 adds up
- Rating
- 44.2/50
- 4.7 stars from 16 reviews, adjusted toward 4.2
- Review volume
- 8.2/20
- 16 public reviews, log-scaled
- Completeness
- 5/20
- PhoneAddress: Not listedLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 62/100
Rating source: serviceagent.ai directory. Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- serviceagent.ai directory
See how 61 adds up
- Rating
- 44.3/50
- 5 stars from 8 reviews, adjusted toward 4.2
- Review volume
- 6.4/20
- 8 public reviews, log-scaled
- Completeness
- 5/20
- PhoneAddress: Not listedLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 61/100
Rating source: serviceagent.ai directory. Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- Rating: Not listed
- BBBA+ (BBB Accredited)
See how 57 adds up
- Rating
- 42/50
- No public reviews found, scored at the neutral prior
- Review volume
- 0/20
- No public reviews found
- Completeness
- 10/20
- PhoneAddressLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 57/100
Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- Rating: Not listed
- BBBA+ (BBB Accredited)
See how 57 adds up
- Rating
- 42/50
- No public reviews found, scored at the neutral prior
- Review volume
- 0/20
- No public reviews found
- Completeness
- 10/20
- PhoneAddressLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 57/100
Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- Rating: Not listed
- BBBA+ (BBB Accredited)
See how 57 adds up
- Rating
- 42/50
- No public reviews found, scored at the neutral prior
- Review volume
- 0/20
- No public reviews found
- Completeness
- 10/20
- PhoneAddressLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 57/100
Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- Rating: Not listed
- BBBA- (BBB Accredited)
See how 57 adds up
- Rating
- 42/50
- No public reviews found, scored at the neutral prior
- Review volume
- 0/20
- No public reviews found
- Completeness
- 10/20
- PhoneAddressLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 57/100
Verified Nov 10, 2026.
- Rating: Not listed
- BBBA+ (BBB Accredited)
See how 57 adds up
- Rating
- 42/50
- No public reviews found, scored at the neutral prior
- Review volume
- 0/20
- No public reviews found
- Completeness
- 10/20
- PhoneAddressLicense: Not listedHours: Not listed
- Years in business
- 5/10
- Not listed, neutral 5 of 10
- Total
- 57/100
Verified Nov 10, 2026.
How the score works
- Rating
- 50
- Public star rating, pulled toward 4.2 until a company has enough reviews to stand on its own.
- Review volume
- 20
- Number of public reviews, log-scaled. Full points at 1,000.
- Completeness
- 20
- 5 each for a phone, a street address, a license and listed hours on public record.
- Years in business
- 10
- Full points at 30 years. Not listed scores a neutral 5.
Not an input: payment. Promoted slots are labeled and never carry a rank number. Ties go to the company with more reviews.
Rate card · Rochester
| Repair | Typical range |
|---|---|
Broken torsion spring (replace) Per spring, parts and labor. Doors with two springs are often replaced as a pair; a pair with drums is about $300 to $700. | $150–$350Estimate |
Broken extension spring (replace) Per spring. Extension springs come in pairs, one per side, and safety cables should be checked at the same visit. | $100–$250Estimate |
Snapped or frayed cable Usually per pair. A cable break often happens with a spring failure. | $100–$300Estimate |
Door off track Low end is realigning a bent track. Higher end includes replacing a track section or rollers. | $125–$350Estimate |
Opener repair Covers sensors, circuit boards, gears and remotes. Parts availability varies by opener age. | $100–$300Estimate |
Opener replacement (installed) Depends on motor type: chain, belt or smart opener. Often worth it when repair cost nears half of a new unit. | $350–$900Estimate |
Damaged panel (replace one section) Depends on door model and whether a matching section is still made. Insulated and custom panels cost more. | $250–$1,200Estimate |
Rollers (replace set) Nylon rollers run quieter than steel. Often done together with a spring service. | $100–$250Estimate |
Service call or diagnostic fee Ask whether the fee is applied to the repair if you approve the work. | $50–$150Estimate |
- Spring replacement $140 to $350 per spring (ranges from Angi, This Old House and Bob Vila as quoted in consumer discussion)
- Two springs plus drums about $300 to $700 considered reasonable by consumer reporters (Scripps News, WFTV, AZFamily)
- Observed local spring replacement ranges: Buffalo $150 to $280, Rochester $180 to $340, Syracuse $150 to $320 (ChatGPT-search proxy, 2026-11-10)
- Cable, off-track, opener, panel, roller and service-call ranges are editorial estimates from public national cost guides; NOT yet verified against local quotes. Re-verify at the next monthly refresh.
- Spring safety guidance: International Door Association (IDA) and manufacturer instructions
Stop using the door if you see
- A loud bang from the garage, followed by a door that will not lift
- A visible gap in the torsion spring above the door
- The door slams down, drops quickly or will not stay open
- A cable hangs loose or is frayed at the bottom bracket
- The door is crooked, with one side higher than the other
- The opener motor runs but the door does not move
- The door is off its track or stuck partly open with a car inside
Keep people and vehicles clear of the door and call a company from the list.
Call the top-ranked companyHow to choose a company
- Ask for a written, itemized quote before any work starts.
- Ask which parts are included and how long the parts and labor warranties last.
- Ask for the company's license or registration details if your town requires one.
- For broken springs, ask whether they replace springs in pairs and what that costs.
- Be wary of a quote that changes a lot once the technician is in your garage.
Garage doors in Rochester
Cold snaps and lake-effect snow along Lake Ontario are a common time for spring and cable failures in Monroe County.
Questions
How much does garage door spring repair cost in Rochester?
Garage door spring replacement in Rochester, NY typically costs $150 to $350 per spring, as of November 2026. A pair of torsion springs with drums is commonly about $300 to $700. Prices vary with spring size, door weight and the time of the visit. Ask for the total in writing before work starts.
Can I open my garage door with a broken spring?
You can, but it is not recommended. A broken spring means the door is its full weight, often well over 100 pounds, and the opener is not built to lift it. Pull the red emergency release only when the door is fully closed, and get a second person to lift. Otherwise leave it and call a technician.
Is it safe to replace a garage door spring myself?
No. Torsion springs hold enough stored energy to cause serious injury, and the International Door Association advises that spring work be done by trained technicians with the correct winding bars. The parts cost little, but a mistake can be costly. Hire a professional for torsion and extension spring replacement.
How do I know if my garage door spring is broken?
The most common signs are a loud bang from the garage, a door that feels very heavy, an opener that strains or only lifts a few inches, and a visible gap in the torsion spring above the door. A door that slams down or will not stay open also points to a spring or cable failure.
What should I ask a garage door repair company before they come out?
Ask for the company's local street address, a quote range for your specific problem, the service call fee and whether it applies to the repair, and license and insurance status. Ask them to put the final price in writing before work starts. A company that will not answer these is a reason to call another.
How can I avoid a bait-and-switch garage door repair quote?
Get a written, itemized quote before work starts and compare it to the ranges on this page. Be cautious of a very low phone price, such as $400 for a pair that later becomes thousands. Consumer reports describe low phone quotes followed by inflated bills. You can decline and pay only the agreed service fee.
How much does a garage door opener repair or replacement cost in Rochester?
Opener repair in Rochester, NY typically costs $100 to $300, as of November 2026. A new installed opener typically runs $350 to $900 depending on motor type. Replacement is worth considering when the opener is over about 10 to 15 years old and the repair costs near half the price of a new unit.
What does it cost to fix a garage door that is off track?
A garage door off track in Rochester, NY typically costs $125 to $350 to repair. Realigning a bent track is at the low end. Replacing a track section or damaged rollers costs more. Do not force an off-track door to move, because it can fall or bend the track further.
Why do garage door springs break more often in winter?
Springs wear with each open and close cycle and are rated for a limited number, commonly 10,000 cycles for standard springs. Cold weather makes metal and lubricants stiffer, and local repair companies in western and central New York report more spring failures in winter. Lubricating springs and rollers yearly can reduce strain.
How do I find a garage door repair company in Rochester, NY?
Compare companies by rating and review count, how complete their public business details are, and years in business. On FixPros, companies are ranked by a published score, and paid placements are labeled Promoted. Call at least two companies for a price range on your repair, and check the address on a map.
Should I repair or replace my garage door?
Repair when the damage is a single part such as a spring, cable, roller or one panel. Consider replacing the door when several panels are damaged, the door is warped, or repair costs approach half of a new door. A new garage door installed typically costs several thousand dollars; get at least two written quotes.
Does a garage door service call fee apply to the repair?
It depends on the company, so ask before the visit. Service call or diagnostic fees typically range from $50 to $150, as of November 2026. Some companies apply the fee to the repair if you approve the work. Ask for this in writing so the final bill matches the quote.
Prefer a callback?
Your request goes to the top 20 companies listed on this page. We don't send marketing texts.